Is WoW too Low Brow?

Pictured: WoW?

Pictured: WoW?

Let me start this post with an admission.  I’ve strayed.  Look, it’s not that I don’t find WoW sexy anymore or think that it’s gotten too old or anything.  WoW’s the same vibrant, sexy game that I have and will always cherish deep in my heart, it’s true.  But still, lately I’ve found myself in the arms of a different game, one that could satisfy needs that WoW simply never could.  Yes, lately my boots have been under the bed of Elder Scrolls IV.

I don’t know how it happened!  There I was in Best Buy, minding my own business in the video game section as I’m want to do when I go to the ol’ double B, when our eyes just locked.  I couldn’t resist her in that cute little game of the year box, with the original game and both expansions included for only twenty bucks.  We tried to play it coy, but before I even knew what was happening, her cellophane was strewn across my floor and, well, let’s just say that I’ve had quite a few late nights lately, if you know what I mean.

However, during my infidelity there was one stark contrast between the games that made me begin to wonder.  You see, super nerds such as myself have usually grown up with their noses deep into the fantasy genre, drinking deeply from the font of the likes of J.R.R. Tolkein, R.A. Salvatore and Robert Jordan.  The thing about writers of this magnitude, however, is that they often write what is commonly considered “high fantasy.”

For those of you not familiar with high fantasy, the best example is Lord of the Rings and the whole Middle-Earth mythos that Tolkien built from scratch.  High fantasy builds on itself, creating lore heavy backgrounds and trying it’s best to not just give you a view of an alternate world, but to submerse you in a wholly fantastic realm.  There’s nothing there other than human beings to remind you of the real world, because fantasy is supposed to be separate from reality.

Now anyone who’s played Elder Scrolls IV knows that this is the type of world you find yourself in when playing that game.  I was thrown into a completely new world, made to explore and find out the rich background and side stories of this digital reality.  It felt like what a fantasy realm should feel like with unbelievable mysteries and intrepid adventuring left and right, allowing me to become Frellen, the Dark Elf Spellsword who closed the Gates of Oblivion and saved Cyrodiil from certain destruction.  Yeah, it was pretty awesome.

But then I come back to WoW.  Now don’t get me wrong, it’s not like I’m saying that WoW is the equivalent of a dirty redneck in overalls shaking hands with the president or anything like that.  WoW does have it’s own rich lore and is constantly compounding it through quests and side material for the game.  However, when compared to other games or fantasy stories, you find something lacking in WoW’s make up.  It doesn’t feel the same.  It’s just not high fantasy.

For one, there’s a lot of real world references, somewhat breaking the fourth wall.  Though fun and often chuckle-worthy, these sort of things do serve to highlight that this is a game world, an unreality.  Real life intrudes upon the setting you’ve placed yourself in and reminds you that it is only a game, just a fantasy, something not real.  Though reminders of real life are important for an MMO, by admitting your falsehood through references such as that, you break the fantasy and take something away from the experience.

Then there’s the cartoonish appearance of the characters and world in general.  With large, over exaggerated, almost caricature like architecture, you occasionally feel as though you may have accidently wandered onto a Saturday morning cartoon.  And though it’s not like the characters bear any sort of resemblance to Mickey Mouse or anything, they definitely do not look real.  Even the humans have what I consider a slight, almost anime-ish sort of quality about them.  This only serves to further separate you from the fantasy of WoW, making you feel less connected with the world of Azeroth than you could.

Some might argue that these are part of WoW’s appeal to the masses at large and I one hundred percent agree to that.  Real world references and subtle reminders that this is just a game and not meant to be looked at seriously as most high fantasy works are does add likability to the game.  11.5 million people can’t be all wrong, after all.  But WoW also loses something off the other end, a feeling of submersion and true fantasy that a lot of us nerds, obviously WoW’s base, yearn for at times.  I don’t believe that the game is losing subscribers by the boatload because of this, but I wander at times whether or not WoW could benefit from a little more fantasy at times.

Either way, though I may spend a few weeks in throes of nerdy passion with this other game, I know that it truly doesn’t mean anything at all.  WoW is still the one for me, the one I’ll always come home to.  Eventually, my Elder Scrolls disk will sit on my CD spindle with Neverwinter Nights, Dawn of War II and all the other games that I have had fleeting trysts with.  In the end, there’s only WoW, patient and understanding of my trifling ways.  

Chicken Butt.



6 Responses to “Is WoW too Low Brow?”

  1. 05/25/2009 at 10:32 AM

    In a way, it’s all about audience. Most of the people who play Elder Scrolls WANT high fantasy, and they -know- that’s what they’ll be getting. WoW can be the greatest thing since sliced bread, fantasy-speaking, but at the end of the day, it’s a business, and it needs to make money.
    If Metzen and co. decide to make it super high-fantasy and what-not, what -if- they do start losing people/not getting subscribers? WoW might not succeed.
    As much as it pains me to say this, it’s the business part of the equation that comes into this. I love Elder Scrolls as well; it most certainly is immersive, but at the end of the day, a pay-per-play thing like WoW needs to succeed, or will die.
    Ugh. I hate business talk. =P

  2. 05/25/2009 at 1:53 PM

    Very good post.

    There is a difference between strict high fantasy and the more relaxed, animated fantasy of WoW. I’m more partial to the second kind. I’m not a huge LOTR fan, and I bore easily at high fantasy stuff. I don’t want to play a game where everything looks perfectly realistic, I want a game that looks like a game. I want a little fun in my games. I’m not saying games like ES4 aren’t fun, but they aren’t “haha” fun. They are “exciting and realistic!” fun. Meh.

    I think it’s the same reason I would rather read a Terry Pratchett novel over Tolkien/Jordan/Salvatore. I prefer “Funtasy” to “Fantasy”!

    The other thing, more specific to these particular games, is they type of game they are. When I think of Elder Scrolls, I think of it as more of an interactive book, where story comes first and then playing the game is just a great way to get more into it.

    But WoW, on the other hand, I play for the gameplay and social aspect. The story is fun and interesting, but in the end, it isn’t really why any of us are there. So they’re allowed to be a little less strict about the environment.

  3. 05/25/2009 at 5:04 PM

    Heh heh heh. I chuckled all thw way through.

    Gobble gobble.

  4. 05/26/2009 at 8:46 AM

    *screams obscenities at the mention of Robert Jordan, gibbers something about shallow female characters and needless filler whilst making stabbing motions, and then runs away*

  5. 5 Scrat!
    05/26/2009 at 4:14 PM

    ” I couldn’t resist her in that cute little game of the year box”

    Some of us will always miss EQ and long for the hardcore titties of another woman.

    WoW does not feel like a challenge anymore.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Posts with the Mosts

Tell me how awesome I am!

Beat the rush and send me an e-mail at: HolyDueg@gmail.com. It's good to have heroes.

%d bloggers like this: